Quietest Wood Stove Heat Fans: Ecofan, VODA, GALAFIRE, Xmasneed

| | , ,

We’ve been using our wood stove heat fan for two years, and now we couldn’t be without it!

I was a bit skeptical about them at first, and even more skeptical once I had it running. However, after using it for two winters now, the heat-powered fan does seem to help heat the parts of the home that are furthest away from our wood-burning stove.

Our stove fan has 5 blades/fins, and it’s about 8 inches tall. It’s not a fancy model like the EcoFan, just one of the cheaper ones. You can see me unboxing it and getting it started in the video below.

Best Stove Top Heat Fans

VODA 4 Blade Wood Burning Stove Fan

  • The best selling heat powered fan on Amazon
  • 8.2" tall, 4 blades
  • Best selling model, very quiet operation, good for starters
View On AmazonView On Home Depot

JossaColar 12 Blade Heat Powered Fan

  • Large 12-blade thermo-electric fan
  • 6.3" wide, 9.8" tall, 4.3" deep
  • A more powerful blower; some people prefer 2x 4 blade fans to face in different directions
View On AmazonView On Lehmans

Ecofan Airmax Fan For Wood Stoves

  • Premium wood stove fans for best results
  • Large 9" blade (2 fins)
  • Other Ecofan sizes and model designs available
View On AmazonView On Tractor Supply

Woodstove heat fans are used to help with air circulation in the home.

They are very quiet (or even silent) and do not require batteries or other electrical input. They are powered by the heat from the wood stove.

When placed on top of your wood stove they help to push the warm air out across the room, rather than letting it rise straight up to the ceiling.

Some wood-burning stoves come with blowers already installed, so a fan is not usually necessary for these models. However, radiant wood-burning stoves can benefit from one or two heat fans.

Our wood-burning stove – a Pyro Classic IV – does not have a blower but warms the house with radient heat. There are parts of the house that don’t heat up as well as others, which is why we decided to buy a heat fan.

This is the model we purchased, but check out the following video to see what it’s like in action (before we painted the wood stove and surrounds).

I said in the video that the fan was probably made of steel, but I’ve since learned that it’s made of Aluminum Alloy.

These heat fans come ready to go and there is no setup required. If you watched the video, you’ll have seen that the most difficult part is getting it out of the box!

Stove Fan Specs And Features

benefits of a wood stove fan
The fan starts running not long after lighting the fire

Most wood stove fans for sale on Amazon, Home Depot, etc. have a very similar design. They all look very much alike and have many of the same features and specs.

The main difference between them all is that they have a different number of blades. Some of the listings say more is better, but I don’t really believe this.

The Ecofan, for example, is one of the most expensive and most effective products, but it only has 2 blades.

The overall construction could be considered superior, and those 2 blades are large (depending on which size you get). This likely makes it better than an 8-blade wood stove fan.

The Cocoon Fan is another very popular model that’s more on the pricey side, and it has 4-blades, but I think it would rival my 5-blade model!

Personally, I’d say it is the size of the blades that is more important than the number of blades, along with the overall build and component quality.

Common/general heat fan specs:

  • Made of aluminum alloy
  • Weighs 1.4 lbs
  • 5-blades
  • 35 dB sound
  • Works up to 660F or 350C
  • Handle for moving even when hot

The speed of the fan varies depending on the temperature of the fire, but it starts operating soon after lighting lighting the log burner.

The fan has a built-in system to stop it from overheating, a “satin anodized efficient blade design,” and virtually silent operation.

Wood fans are powered by transforming heat into energy, without using any battery or electricity.

Heat fans can be damaged if the wood stove gets too hot, but they are extremely resilient to very hot fires. Best to remove it if you have a fire roaring for an extended time.

You can also buy a wood stove thermometer to help monitor the temperature of your wood stove and keep it within that ideal operating range. 

Wood Stove Heat Fan Review

are wood burning stove fans good
The hotter the fire, the faster the fan will run

As I said in the intro, we’ve been using this wood-burning stove heat fan for two years (or two Falls, Winters, and Springs – as we’re in a cold climate).

The fan has made a noticeable difference in the time it takes to warm the house, and it also warms certain areas to an extent they were never heated before!

The heat fan is very quiet – you can’t hear any noise from it at all unless you’re right up close and paying attention. And, it’s a cool design as well. It doesn’t require any maintenance other than giving it a bit of a dust every couple of months.

 

 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

A post shared by Fire And Saw (@fireandsaw)

We like how it powers itself, works away hour after hour, and never gives up. These little devices are under a lot of strain in some ways, so I’m surprised it’s still as good as new after 2 years.

Pros:

  • Very quiet or even silent operation
  • No set-up or maintenance required
  • Pushes warm air through the house
  • Solid durable construction that lasts for years
  • Something everyone notices and comments on

Cons:

  • Perhaps a larger fan would make even more difference
  • Some versions are pricey, but there are budget-friendly models as well
  • Some people don’t notice a difference and find them to be gimmicky

Alternative Heat Powered Fans

heat fan not working
How the fan looks when not operating

Cheap heat stove fans such as the one we bought are the most popular. You can pick them up for between $20 – $50.

Some examples:

And then there are thermoelectric fans in the $50 – $150 range. These brands and models are typically built from higher quality components and have large blades.

Examples include:

Ecofan heat fans are certainly the leaders when it comes to these heat-powered devices, but they can cost between 2 and 5 times the price of the cheaper versions.

The Ecofans tend to last even longer, being made from higher-quality materials and are certainly worth the investment. However, that’s all going to depend on how much you want to spend.

In our experience, there’s nothing wrong with the $20 – $30 fans!

Thermo-Electric Fan FAQs

budget friendly wood stove fan
This is very much a budget-friendly heat fan

Are wood stove fans dangerous?

They can be if used incorrectly.

Make sure you use them within the temperature parameters they are designed to be used at. They are not to be positioned in front of or near the chimney.

Can you move a heat fan once it’s running?

Our instruction manual says not to move it once it’s operating.

However, it does have a handle that does not get hot so that we can move it if necessary. We do move it from time to time, like when we’re boiling a bone broth on the stovetop.

Also, it’s OK to move it to face it in another direction. Sometimes when ours is facing towards the bedrooms they get too hot so we will turn it around to face the living areas.

Do wood stove fans really work?

Yes, ours does!

As stated above, we were skeptical at first, but it has made a noticeable difference. The other side of the house is much warmer now.

Where is the best place to put a fan on a log burner?

Put the fan on top of the stove away from the chimney.

Every woodstove is different, but usually, this means placing it at the front left or front right.

Are 2 stove fans better than one?

Yes, 2 stove fans are better than one.

You can put one on each of the front corners of your burner and point them out in different directions. This is a common method of heating the entire house with a wood stove.

How many blades should a stove fan have?

The number of blades really doesn’t matter too much.

Rather, it’s the size of the blade. 4 small blades will likely be less effective than 2 large blades.

There are very good heat fans with 2 blades, and there are very good heat fans with 8. It’s about the overall quality of the product.

How do you use a wood-burning stove fan?

Simply place the heat fan on the top of the woodstove away from the chimney.

Once the fire has started to warm up, the fan will start operating automatically.

There are no switches to turn it on or off, nor does it require any batteries.

Heat Powered Wood Stove Fans

Wood burner heat fans are great little devices – they don’t have to cost a lot, but they do make a significant difference.

Plus, if you’re into wood stoves, you’ve got to try out all the different accessories, right?

It would be rude not to.

Whether you have a regular stove, a mini wood-burning stove, a wood cookstove, or even an antique stove, one of these fans can likely help you heat your home better.

They would even work well with a coal-burning stove as long as you’re keeping an eye on the temperature. Coal will burn much hotter than wood.

Let us know if you have any questions below, and feel free to share your experiences with wood stove fans – we’d love to hear them!

Previous

10 TOP Bar And Chain Oils Reviewed: Stihl, Husqvarna, ECHO, Oregon…

5 BEST Firewood Moisture Meters: Wood Moisture Meter Reviews

Next

Leave a Comment